Royalties

Because of the debate regarding the Resource Super Profits Tax
we put together this page outlining some of the royalties and the conditions that currently apply.

A Royalty is a State Tax.

Actually, all the States go to great length to explain that it is not a tax.

NSW calls it: "a charge for the transfer of the right to extract a mineral resource."
In the NT it is "a charge for resource usage"

For the mining company this is not just a matter of taking the stuff out of the ground and "who do we make the royalty cheque out to?"


Royalties can be charged as

  • a fixed amount, as in so many dollars per tonne or
  • a percentage of the value

Royalties vary from State to State.

  • one state may charge a fixed dollar amount per tonne,
  • another state may charge a different amount, for the same commodity.
  • one state may charge a fixed amount,
  • another state may charge a percentage, for the same commodity

Royalties vary depending on the commodity mined, and there are many different minerals.
For example well known resources like:

  • Bauxite (Aluminium)
  • Copper
  • Gold
  • Iron Ore
  • and Yellow Cake (Uranium)

But also commodities like

  • Clay/shale
  • Coal
  • Diamond
  • Gypsum
  • Limestone
  • Lithium
  • Marble
  • Peat
  • Phosphate
  • and Structural clay

Then there are minerals most people have never even heard of like

  • Apatite
  • Bismuth
  • Columbium
  • Halite
  • Leucoxene
  • Pyrophyllite
  • Staurolite
  • and Wollastonite

Royalties vary depending on the conditions as to when they apply.
from one mineral to the next,
even how it is mined - for example NSW coal:

  • 8.2% of value of open cut coal
  • 7.2% of value of underground coal
  • 6.2% of value of deep underground coal

or, in the case of Petroleum (Oil and Gas) whether this is "onshore" or on "Submerged Lands".

In the case of petroleum products the royalty can even vary depending on the age of the project or the size of the field.

Therefore, before a miner can write a cheque, they have to determine:

  • Which State
  • Which mineral
  • fixed amount or percentage
  • how was it mined
  • How old is the project
  • What is the size of the project
  • What are the allowable deductions

It's an administrative Nightmare!

This is why Dr Henry wrote in "The Henry Tax Review":

Recommendation 45: The current resource charging arrangements imposed on
non-renewable resources by the Australian and State governments should be replaced by a
uniform resource rent tax imposed and administered by the Australian government

If this was implemented, it would be real reform, welcomed by the miners.
It would be simple.

  • Work out what your profit is; write out a cheque to Canberra for the royalties.

It would not matter whether the commodity was gold or sand, above ground or under ground, you pay tax on the profit.

Small profit, small tax, large profit, lots of tax.

So why does the government not do this?

The big problem is that royalties are a State Tax.
The federal government would have to sit down with the State Governments and negotiate.
Some states may receive more and others would receive less.

Another reason is that a lot of the royalties are fixed. State governments can project into the future how much money they will receive.
For example the NSW government will receive 35 cents per tonne of bauxite.
The only variable is how many tonnes have been taken out of the ground.

Under the new tax system the amount the Government collects depends on the profit the miners make, which depends largely on the price they can get for the particular commodity at that time.
If the world price of aluminium goes up, the value of Bauxite would increase and NSW would receive more.
Conversely, if the world price for aluminium goes down, NSW would receive less.
And nobody can predict future price movements.

Mr Rudd's solution?
In his eyes, the best of both worlds.
Charge the tax, but give credit for the royalties that the miners still have to pay.

The advantage (To Mr Rudd)

  • The states still collect the royalties as per normal, therefore
  • No need to negotiate with the States
  • When the miners make a profit, Canberra will collect additional tax.

Royalties by State


Western Australia

Petroleum royalties are administered and collected under State and Commonwealth legislation.
Royalties collected for onshore projects are retained by the State Government, while offshore royalties
are shared between the State and Commonwealth in accordance with the relevant legislation.

Understanding Petroleum Royalties

Petroleum royalties are levied on petroleum production onshore, within coastal waters and the North West Shelf Project.
Total petroleum royalties collected in 2007-08 amounted to A$1.25 billion.
The rate of royalty is normally set at between 10–12.5% of the wellhead value of petroleum produced.
In addition to State royalties, Commonwealth legislation provides for an excise on all oil and condensate produced from fields of greater than 4.8 GL (30 MMbbl).
The first 4.8 GL (30 MMbbl) is excise exempt.  Currently there are no onshore fields which are large enough to pay these taxes.
Generally, there are three systems used for the collection of petroleum royalties:

  • Wellhead Royalty;
  • Resource Rent Royalty;
  • Petroleum Resource Rent Tax.

Petroleum royalties are administered and collected under State and Commonwealth legislation. Royalties collected for onshore projects are retained by the State government, while offshore projects are shared between the State and Commonwealth in accordance with the relevant legislation.

Barrow Island onshore royalties are also shared between the Commonwealth and the State.

 

Wellhead Royalty

The well-head value is derived by taking the gross value of petroleum recovered and deducting all costs incurred between a defined valve on the christmas tree and the point of sale.  Deductible costs are normally confined to the processing, storage and transport of the petroleum recovered by the producer to the point of sale. All other costs, including costs associated with exploration, drilling, recovery and abandonment are not deductible.

Understanding Wellhead Royalty

The defined location of the well-head and the methodology for calculation of well-head value are usually included in a royalty schedule specific to each producer.

New petroleum projects landward of the outer limit of the Territorial Sea are subject to either the Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Act 1982 (WA) or Petroleum Act 1967 (WA).  In either case the well-head royalty regime applies with the following elements:

  • Royalty return - generally required to be submitted on a monthly basis
  • Gross value - value of petroleum recovered, generally the arms length sales plus the change in petroleum inventories
  • Royalty rate - 10 per cent or 12.5 per cent (refer royalty rate section) 
  • Allowable deductions - post well-head costs
  • Deduction limit - 50 per cent of gross value for oil projects and 90 per cent of gross value for gas projects

Gross Value

Gross value is the value of petroleum recovered. It includes the value of arms length sales and the change in stocks of petroleum products.  Opening and closing stocks are valued according to the weighted average unit price of the past month's sales. Transactions denominated in foreign currency are converted to Australian dollars based on Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) mid-rates as published weekly by the RBA and daily in the Australian Financial Review.

Allowable Deductions

Three types of costs are allowed to be deducted against the gross value to determine well-head value:

  • Post well-head operating costs
  • Depreciation on commissioned post well-head assets
  • Cost of borrowing on commissioned post well-head assets
  • Post well-head operating costs

Usually at the beginning of a project expected operating costs are itemised by a prospective producer.
Post well-head percentages are then agreed between the State and for each operating cost item.

Depreciation on commissioned post well-head assets

Usually at the beginning of a project a depreciation calculation is negotiated between the State and producer and set out in an agreed schedule.
A straight line depreciation calculation normally applies.

Cost of borrowing on commissioned post well-head assets

The well-head value system allows a producer to deduct from the gross value an amount in recognition of the cost of raising funds related to post well-head assets of the project.
This amount is calculated from the time each post well-head asset is commissioned.

Not all costs of raising funds are allowed.
A gearing allowance is determined at the beginning of the project, usually set at a maximum of 50 per cent of the total cost of post well-head assets.
The term or write-down period of the deduction is also determined at the beginning of a project and proxies the length of time it will take for the project owners to repay their borrowed funds.  
A standard interest rate is used instead of the actual interest rates paid for funds by individual project owners.
The standard rate is usually the 5 year term bond rate as published in the preceding month by the RBA.

Deduction Limits

Deductible costs can vary up to a limit of 50 per cent of the gross value of production for oil projects or 90 per cent of the gross value of production for gas projects for each royalty period.
The choice of the deduction limit is determined by the 'predominant' nature of the project, and may change as a project shifts from a predominantly oil to a predominantly gas project.
Any undeducted expenditure is carried forward to the next month.


Resource Rent Royalty

The Barrow Island Royalty Variation Agreement Act 1982 was agreed between the producer, the State and the Commonwealth as an incentive for the continued maintenance of the wells on Barrow Island to ensure optimal recovery of oil.

Understand Resource Rent Royalty

The resource rent royalty (RRR) replaced the well-head royalty and excise system that had previously applied.

RRR is a royalty based on a percentage of net cash flow. The key aspects are as follows:

  • All allowable expenditure, both current and capital, is written off when incurred.
    However exploration costs incurred more than a year prior to the application of the RRR are not allowable
  • Any excess of costs over revenues are carried forward and compounded at a ‘threshold’ rate
  • Any excess income over the threshold rate is charged to RRR at the rate of 40 per cent
  • RRR is a primary tax before income tax, and is deductible against that tax
  • The revenue is shared 75 per cent to the Commonwealth, 25 per cent to the State

The higher Commonwealth share reflects the far larger proportion of Commonwealth entitlements under the prior royalty and excise regime.

By agreement between the Commonwealth and the State, the State maintains full responsibility for the administration of the RRR regime.


Petroleum Resource Rent Tax

The Petroleum Resource Rent Tax (PRRT) is a secondary tax based on a project’s profitability, and applies to all petroleum products from a project (i.e. crude oil, natural gas, LPG condensate but not value added products, such as LNG) in Commonwealth waters.

Petroleum Resource Rent Tax (PRRT)

PRRT does not apply to the North West Shelf project or to petroleum operations in the Joint Petroleum Development Area between Australia and East Timor.
Royalties do not apply to fields chargeable to PRRT, but PRRT is deductible against income tax.

PRRT is a profit based project tax.
It is applied at a rate of 40 percent to a project’s taxable profit (project income less project expenditure, project exploration expenditure and exploration expenditure transferred in from other related PRRT projects).

Petroleum projects are generally entitled to deduct exploration expenditure transferred from related projects.

Exploration expenditures that are not deducted in the tax year in which they are incurred can be uplifted and carried forward to be used as deductions in subsequent years.

 All project expenditures and payments of PRRT are tax deductible. In the 2007 Budget, the government announced several changes to the petroleum resource rent tax (PRRT) regime.

These changes are:

  • the introduction of a functional currency rule similar to the rule for income tax.
    The functional currency rule will allow oil and gas producers to elect to work out their PRRT position in a foreign currency and this will reduce the costs of compliance;
  • the introduction of a ‘look-back’ rule for exploration expenditure.
    This change will ensure that all exploration expenditure is deductible for PRRT purposes; and
  • the removal of an inconsistency in the ‘external petroleum’ provisions to address the circumstances where two or more petroleum projects are not independent of each other.
    This will ensure that a tolling fee received is treated as a PRRT receipt and the expense incurred to process the product is treated as a PRRT deduction.

Through its key features it provides a fiscal regime that encourages the exploration and production of petroleum, while ensuring an adequate return to the community for the exploitation of these non-renewable resources.
In 2006/2007, PRRT collections were over $1.56 billion, the majority of which came from Bass Strait.


Petroleum Legislation

There are five Acts that apply in Western Australia:

  • The Offshore Petroleum (Royalty) Act 2006, which covers production from fields originating from the North West Shelf project areas covered by permits WA-1-P and WA-28-P. This is an area of Commonwealth jurisdiction in which a wellhead value royalty system is used.
  • The Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Act 1982 which covers fields within a defined coastal waters area, generally being 3 nautical miles seaward from the baseline, as well as certain ‘subsisting’ permit areas located within State inland waters. The State administers a wellhead value royalty system.
  • The Petroleum Resources Rent Tax Assessment Act 1987 applies to all offshore waters seaward of the outer limit of coastal waters other than the North West Shelf project Area. The Commonwealth administers a resource rent tax, which is effectively a profit-based tax levied on a project. It replaced a wellhead royalty and excise system.
  • The Petroleum and Geothermal Energy Resources Act 1967 applies to onshore areas and waters landward of the baseline of the coastal waters, other than ‘subsisting’ permit areas under the Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Act 1982. The State administers a wellhead value royalty system.
  • The Barrow Island Royalty Variation Agreement Act 1982 applies only to Barrow Island. The royalty regime was developed in negotiations between the WAPET consortium, the State and the Commonwealth. It replaced the wellhead royalty and excise system that had previously applied.

NSW

Mining royalties in NSW are payable on minerals. Royalties are divided into non-coal royalties, coal royalties and petroleum royalties.

A mineral royalty is the price charged by the Crown for the transfer of the right to extract a mineral resource. The price (royalty rate) is prescribed in legislation.

Petroleum royalties

Currently, royalty is payable at the rate of 10% of the ‘well-head value’ of the petroleum.
The well head is the point where the petroleum reaches the surface and the ‘well-head value’ is the revenue and/or savings from the generation of electricity after deducting costs incurred downstream of the well head.

For titles granted or renewed after 21 August 1992, under the Petroleum (Onshore) Act 1991, the rate of royalty for the first five years of commercial production is nil; and for the sixth year 6%, rising by 1% each year up to 10% of the well-head value in the tenth year. 

 

Mineral Royalty rate
Agate 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Agricultural lime 35 cents per tonne
Antimony 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Apatite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Arsenic 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Asbestos 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Barite 70 cents per tonne
Bauxite 35 cents per tonne
Bentonite (including Fuller's Earth) 70 cents per tonne
Beryllium minerals 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Bismuth 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Borates 70 cents per tonne
Cadmium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Caesium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Calcite 40 cents per tonne
Chalcedony 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Chert 35 cents per tonne
Chlorite 70 cents per tonne
Chromite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Clay/shale 35 cents per tonne
Coal 8.2% of value of open cut coal
7.2% of value of underground coal
6.2% of value of deep underground coal
Cobalt 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Columbium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Copper 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Corundum 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Cryolite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Diamond 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Diatomite 70 cents per tonne
Dimension stone 70 cents per tonne
Dolomite 40 cents per tonne
Emerald 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Emery 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Feldspathic materials 70 cents per tonne
Fluorite 70 cents per tonne
Galena 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Garnet 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Geothermal substances 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Germanium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Gold 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Graphite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Gypsum 35 cents per tonne
Halite (incl. solar salt) 40 cents per tonne
Ilmenite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Indium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Iron minerals 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Jade 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Kaolin 70 cents per tonne
Lead 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Leucoxene 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Limestone 40 cents per tonne
Lithium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Magnesite 70 cents per tonne
Magnesium salts 40 cents per tonne
Manganese 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Marble 70 cents per tonne
Marine aggregate 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Mercury 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Mica 70 cents per tonne
Mineral pigments 70 cents per tonne
Molybdenite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Monazite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Nephrite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Nickel 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Niobium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Oil shale 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Olivine 70 cents per tonne
Opal 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Ores of silicon 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Peat 70 cents per tonne
Perlite 70 cents per tonne
Petroleum nil first 5 years increasing to 10% at end of 10th year
Phosphates 70 cents per tonne
Platinum group minerals 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Platinum 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Potassium minerals 70 cents per tonne
Potassium salts 40 cents per tonne
Pyrophyllite 70 cents per tonne
Quartz crystal 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Quartzite 70 cents per tonne
Rare earth minerals 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Reef quartz 70 cents per tonne
Rhodonite 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Rubidium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Ruby 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Rutile 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Sapphire 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Scandium and its ores 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Selenium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Serpentine 70 cents per tonne
Sillimanate-group minerals 70 cents per tonne
Silver 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Sodium salts 40 cents per tonne
Staurolite 70 cents per tonne
Strontium minerals 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Structural clay 35 cents per tonne
Sulphur 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Talc 70 cents per tonne
Tantalum 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Thorium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Tin 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Topaz 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Tourmaline 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Tungsten and its ores 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Turquoise 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Vanadium 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Vermiculite 70 cents per tonne
Wollastonite 70 cents per tonne
Zeolites 70 cents per tonne
Zinc 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Zircon 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)
Zirconia 4% ex-mine value (value less allowable deductions)

NSW minerals & petroleum - Royalty rates legislation


QLD

Mining and petroleum royalties

A royalty represents a payment to the state for the right of use of the state's mineral and petroleum resources. Generally royalty is payable when mineral or petroleum is sold, disposed of or used.

Commodity
Rate
Comments
Policy & other references
Petroleum
(including - oil, condensate, natural gas, LPG, coal seam methane)
10% of wellhead value  

Policy No. 68 - Clarification of revenues and allowable deductions in establishing wellhead value under Section 148 of the Petroleum and Gas (Production and Safety) Regulation 2004 (PDF - 81KB).

Petroleum Industry Royalty Issues paper (PDF - 211KB).


NT

Petroleum Royalties

Overview

The petroleum royalty scheme

Division 5, Part III of the Petroleum Act levies a royalty on the production of petroleum in the Northern Territory. Petroleum is defined as a naturally occurring:

  a. hydrocarbon, whether in a gaseous, liquid or solid state;
  b. mixture of hydrocarbons, whether in a gaseous, liquid or solid state; or
  c. mixture of one or more hydrocarbons, whether in a gaseous, liquid or solid state, with hydrogen sulphide, nitrogen, helium or carbon dioxide or any combination of them,

and includes a hydrocarbon as defined by paragraph (a), (b) or (c) that has been returned to a natural reservoir, but does not include a substance which, in its naturally occurring state, is not recoverable from a well by conventional means.

It is not a tax but a charge for resource usage and is payable by the licensee of a production licence to the Government as owner of the site or the petroleum rights over the site.
The overall objective of the royalty is to maximise the contribution of the industry to the long-term welfare of the Northern Territory.

Rate, calculation and payment of royalty

Royalty is calculated at a rate of 10 per cent on the gross value at the wellhead of all petroleum products produced from the licence area.
In general terms, this value is calculated by deducting allowable costs from the point that a market value can be independently established for the product (usually the point of sale) back to the wellhead.
Royalty is payable on a monthly basis with a return detailing the actual liability to be lodged at the end of each royalty year.